Fantasy draft analysis is done to death. Every sports-related website has their own take and analysis on who you should draft for your fantasy team. But not a single one of these websites (to our knowledge) does a draft analysis based on how cute the players are. Not a one!! As a girl myself, I find this to be ridiculous. You do not want a team full of ugly-ass players! Even though you are supposed to root for them, how can you when you are forced to look at dreadlocks and mangled faces?
So for us women that participate in fantasy football, we are trying something new this year with our first annual fantasy football draft analysis - Keisha and Kim style. We will take the average of the player’s “real” fantasy ranking along with our “cute” ranking and average the two to help you determine who should allow to be on your team.
Before you start saying that this is sexist and some women take fantasy football just as seriously as the boys out there – take note: how many times has someone you know (or even you) bitched about how some random girl/guy won their March Madness office pool by picking teams based on how cute the mascots are or which team had the prettier colors or even what team their favorite fictional character went to for college? EXACTLY.
Without further ado, here are our rankings (along with a little commentary, some helpful, some just for fun).
1. Adrian Peterson - ESPN Ranking - 1
If you are like me, you want to yell out his name Rocky Balboa-style every time you hear it. And I haven’t even seen those movies. Although he is still a bit of a fumbler, if your league is like mine, that doesn’t count against you. The boy can still run and score touchdowns, and really, what else do you want in a running back? Plus he is super hot and was just on the cover of ESPN the Magazine. Although he went to one of my college’s rivals – Oklahoma – you can’t help but love the guy.
2. Tom Brady - ESPN Ranking - 20
Tthis ranking definitely depends on Brady not having the Beiber hairstyle. Ugh. Giselle, you are hot, but come on, let the boy have a decent haircut! Also, don’t let him dance ridiculously. He loses cool points every time. He is getting up there in football age at 34, but he still is considered one of the top QBs in the game and the players around him are definitely improving.
3. Jeremy Maclin – ESPN Ranking 41
Okay, he might have gotten a bit of this ranking based on the fact he went to my college (Mizzou), but that does not make him any less adorable. Plus his dog is almost as cute (if not cuter) than him. Quite the package indeed. He is the #2 receiver for what many are considering the “dream team” this year in football, and with a rejuvenated Vick throwing him the ball, he should have a great season.
4. LeSean McCoy – ESPN Ranking - 8
I may be a bit biased on this guy as well, as he was on my fantasy football team last year (and hopefully this year) and I tend to get a bit attached to my players, but the boy is sexy. He can run, he can catch, he can run and catch, what more do you want? He is also considered a top 10 RB this year, so add him to your team!!
5. Ray Rice – ESPN Ranking - 6
I just find this boy adorable. Kinda tiny, but he runs real fast! Plays for one of my least favorite teams in football, but I will let that slide. He is a top 10 RB and player for fantasy this year. Plus, who else is going to score on that team?
6. Aaron Rodgers – ESPN Ranking - 7
He just was the Super Bowl MVP. Played a ridiculous January. Still young at 27. #1 QB according to ESPN. I am super sad that he will probably not be on my fantasy team this year due to the boys in the league who like to see me fussy and throwing fits. Oh and he puts on championship belts like no other, which I love, being a closeted WWE fan.
7. Drew Brees – ESPN Ranking - 16
Has a Super Bowl ring to his name as well. Super charitable and is considered one of the reasons New Orleans is returning to glory. You cannot help but love him and his adorable kiddos. Still relatively young and has a ridiculous amount of talented receivers to throw to.
8. Reggie Wayne – ESPN Ranking - 28
My partner Keisha’s favorite player. Pretty damn cute, even though he plays for my least favorite team OF ALL TIME. I will let that slide in this instance. But just this one time. Easily Peyton’s favorite target in Indy.
9. Michael Vick – ESPN Ranking - 10
Dogfighting aside, Vick is damn talented. He does it all out on the field, throwing for six TDs in a game last season. Another member of the anointed “dream team” in Philly. Should do great things again this year as long as he can stay healthy. If you didn’t know, running QBs tend to die an early death (cough, Daunte Culpepper, cough). However, he had a couple of seasons off in the middle of his career. Granted he was in prison, but nevertheless.
10. Mike Wallace – ESPN Ranking - 24
I ranked Mr. Wallace this high mostly based on his faux-hawk. I am a sucker for those. Do not ask me why because I obviously do not have an answer. Pittsburgh is still a great team and Wallace is listed as #1 on the depth chart.
11. Miles Austin – ESPN Ranking - 31
Ahh you could just get lost in his eyes. No longer a secret after a couple of 250 receiving yard games in his back pocket, he is the #1 WR on America’s Team. Dated a Kardashain, but we will let that slide for this. Just this once though.
12. Marques Colston – ESPN Ranking - 43
Considered a problem child coming out of college, Colston has definitely left that reputation in the past. He is an injury risk as he has missed a great deal of games in his short career. Also has a Super Bowl ring, and you know how we girls love our jewelry!!
13. DeSean Jackson – ESPN Ranking - 32
Human highlight reel. Scored one of the most exciting TDs I have personally ever seen last year against the Giants. A bit of an injury risk as he is a slight man, but is cocky enough to make up for it.
14. Phillip Rivers – ESPN Ranking - 29
Although as a player, I think he is a bit annoying and kinda mean, I can’t discount his looks. After all, that is what these rankings are all about!! Puts up huge numbers every year even when his supporting cast isn’t much to look at. Plays in Cali which adds bonus points as well.
15. Maurice Jones-Drew – ESPN Ranking - 5
A tiny guy, only about my height, but he packs a punch in those inches! A top 10 fantasy player every year since entering the league, he is still young enough to keep putting up huge numbers. Plus, there isn’t a whole lot else going on in Jacksonville, so that helps as well. An adorable man.
16. Tony Romo – ESPN Ranking - 42
Dated every gorgeous blonde from Texas to California, but don’t let that bias you towards him. I love that he is like a kid with his backwards hats he is always wearing. If he can stay healthy this year, he should have another great season. Plus he married a former Miss Missouri (my home state), so he gets extra points for that!
17. Santonio Holmes – ESPN Ranking - 49
Although he plays for my 2nd most-hated team, there is something about him flying around on the field that puts him up this high in my rankings. Plus he has a cool name. Even though he has Mr. Tight White Pants Sanchez throwing to him, they were amazing last year in the 4th quarter for most of the season staging dramatic comebacks and earning themselves the nickname – the Cardiac Jets. And he had the amazing TD in the Super Bowl a couple of years ago against the Cardinals.
18. Andre Johnson – ESPN Ranking - 9
The only WR to find his way into ESPN’s Top 10, the man is just huge! Who can defend against someone that big? It is beyond me. He is a pretty quiet guy and keeps playing for a team that seems doomed to never make it to the playoffs, so I like the fact that he is not a distraction.
19. Hakeem Nicks – ESPN Ranking - 17
He went to college at UNC – my favorite basketball team. The football team….well there isn’t much good to say about them. Nevertheless, he is another huge WR that I personally would find hard to defend against. But of course, that is why I do not play professional football.
20. Calvin Johnson – ESPN Ranking - 18
Has the nickname Megatron which is just awesome. Props if you know why. Plus I have had a thing for this man ever since he was still playing football for Georgia Tech and was named to ESPN the Magazine’s “Next” list. And if you have seen the commercial with him in a suit…………….oh! what was I saying? Anyway, plays in a crappy city but still manages to put up pretty decent numbers season in and out. He will frustrate you if you end up with him on your team as he will have no points going into the fourth quarter and then out of nowhere have a 90 yard TD. I traded him away last year and still kinda regret it. Ah well.
21. Darren McFadden – ESPN Ranking - 21
Was awesome in college and then…..well he was injured so I will let it slide. Plays for a horrible team that is owned by a dead man, but still is a pretty decent RB. Plus he isn’t too bad to look at. So yeah, there’s that.
22. Knowshon Moreno – ESPN Ranking - 38
If you can get past his name (what in the world does Knowshon mean anyway), he is pretty cute. Plays in the Mile High city (I am gonna leave the dirty joke out of this) that has a bit of a revolving door of coaches the past few years. Gets injured easily (or at least it seems so to me).
23. Jahvid Best – ESPN Ranking - 45
Another Detroit player. Just glad he doesn’t have to play against their defense. I am getting far enough down in the list, that there isn’t too much new to say in the looks department. I would put him at middle of the road in the looks department. Perhaps that is why he is just about halfway down the list. Look how that works!
24. Ryan Mathews – ESPN Ranking - 35
Injured almost the entire season last year. A friend of mine took him as his #1 overall pick. Silly rabbit. He is one-half of the running back tandem in San Diego and I personally think most of the TDs will go to the other – Tolbert. Not much to say about his skills because I haven’t really seen the boy play yet. Has a cute face though.
25. Greg Jennings – ESPN Ranking - 14
If I were to rank my favorite players, Jennings would definitely be higher up the list. However, this isn’t a favorite players ranking, it is hottest/cutest/most adorable ranking. So therefore, he falls in the bottom half. Plays for the current Super Bowl champion and is easily their best and most exciting (outside of Rodgers) player on offense.
26. Michael Turner – ESPN Ranking - 15
I like big butts and I cannot lie…so yeah the boy has some junk in the trunk. Perhaps it is just an extension of those huge ass legs that power him down the field. Used to be Tomlinson’s backup in San Diego, but once the boy got out of his shadow, he proved he could stand on his own.
27. Peyton Manning – ESPN Ranking - 22
Ugh. I do not like him. Yeah, I said it. One of the NFL’s most loved players. So of course, I don’t care for him. Getting up there in age, but still can put up MVP numbers…if the players around him stay healthy. Towards the end of last season, he was anything but invincible. Hopefully his WRs and RBs learn how to stay off the injured list this year.
28. Antonio Gates – ESPN Ranking - 36
Another player that the Big Butts song could have been written about. What is it about tight ends having large asses? I guess because they are also used for blocking. I dunno. Was hilarious on one of my favorite shows, The League, a few years ago. Tends to get injured more as he gets older. Obviously.
29. Peyton Hillis – ESPN Ranking - 25
Single-handedly kept the fantasy football championship within my reach last year. Came out of nowhere to put up huge numbers week after week. Of course, I traded him. I can’t say I am too upset about this because players that put up such ridiculous numbers one year (especially running backs) usually do not equal that in the next. Cute guy even though his neck is probably the size of my thigh.
30. Rashard Mendenhall - ESPN Ranking - 12
He is right on the cusp of being on my “I probably wouldn’t think much of him if he didn’t play football” list. But oh yea, he DOES play football. And for one of the best teams. And he isn’t too bad looking.
31. Matt Forte – ESPN Ranking - 27
I cannot decide if I think Mr. Forte is cute or not. Believe me, I have spent some time trying to figure it out. Maybe he just takes bad pictures? I dunno. Either way, had a monster season a couple of years ago, last year…not so much. I think he will be back this year though. As long as his QB stops dating reality TV stars.
32. Larry Fitzgerald – ESPN Ranking - 23
I don’t like dreads. Or braids. Or long hair in general on a man. Fitzy falls under these categories. However, I think if he would cut his hair I would start to dig him more. So that’s why he isn’t scraping the bottom. Plus he is kind of one of the best receivers in the game. No idea who is throwing to him this year. (Okay, I do know, but seriously, it’s Kevin “Korn on the” Kolb. I was better off saying, “I don’t know.”)
33. Arian Foster – ESPN Ranking - 2
Came out of NOWHERE last year. Literally. Nowhere. Did you have any idea of who he was before last year? Yeah, I didn’t think so. Might not hold up this well this year since everyone knows who the hell he is. Still #1 RB in Houston though. I can’t say much about his looks. I looked at him a couple of hours ago on ESPN.com and I have kinda forgot. Hence why he is down low, low, low (sorry started singing “Get Low” in my head there for a minute).
34. Brandon Lloyd – ESPN Ranking - 46
Had him on my fantasy team last year. Put up some huge ass games. On the lower end of the Top 50 from ESPN and the lower end of my rankings as well. I can take him or I can leave him in the looks department. I give him a 5 out of 10.
35. Vincent Jackson – ESPN Ranking - 26
I really hope Mr. Jackson doesn’t read this (or his momma) cause he is kind of a jackass. Thinks he is worth more than he is. Not all that great to look at either. Probably the #1 WR for the Chargers this year…if he stays on the field. Sorry, Mrs. Jackson.
36. Dez Bryant – ESPN Ranking - 34
Gets into the news for all of the wrong reasons. Has tons of potential if he keeps his mouth shut and stays out of malls. One of my favorite players of all time – Deion Sanders – gave up on him. I can’t say I am far behind if his play on the field doesn’t help us forget his mouth.
37. BenJarvus Green-Ellis – ESPN Ranking - 48
The Law Firm. Another member of the long hair dreads committee. He plays for my favorite team though. And like Fitzy up above, if he cut his hair, he could find himself moving up my list. For this year though, he is down low. (I promise not to break into song again.)
38. LaGarrette Blount – ESPN Ranking - 44
Has a bit of a temper which has gotten him into trouble in college and in the NFL. Of course if my mom named me LaGarrette, I would probably have a chip on my shoulder too. Should be the #1 RB in Tampa Bay this year on a team that has a great deal of potential. Still really young and last year, once he started playing, was one of the top RBs in the game. However, he falls down low because well, he ain’t cute. Word.
39. Jonathan Stewart – ESPN Ranking - 40
Forget about this guy all of the time. Another player that I couldn’t pick out of a lineup if I had to. Plays behind DeAngelo Williams on the NFL’s worst team (if we are going off last year’s stats). His name is somewhat forgettable too…perhaps that’s why he is close to the bottom of our list.
40. Frank Gore – ESPN Ranking - 13
This man is the definition of a crap shoot. He is either going to be amazing or you are going to waste a high draft pick on him. I personally won’t be taking the risk unless I absolutely have to. Does play in in the division that most college teams could do better than though, so you never know!
41. Matt Schaub – ESPN Ranking - 47
Great QB when he wants to be. Plays on a team that should be better than it is. Houston’s offense last year was great, the defense…not so much. Hopefully with a new defensive coordinator this year, the team will improve. This does not take away from the fact that the man is losing his hair. Damn those helmets! I wonder if he wears a cowboy hat in the offseason….those too are hair killers.
42. Dallas Clark – ESPN Ranking - 50
Old dude, but probably Peyton’s second favorite target. Has been getting himself injured more though. His name makes me think he should be driving a race car though. Maybe once he retires?
43. Roddy White – ESPN Ranking - 11
Come on down! Sorry, I couldn’t pass that quite obvious joke up. I am a simple-minded person. Has way weird hair, but a great WR. I ended up with him at the end of the season last year on my fantasy team and was quite upset that I could not keep him for this year. However, when we are looking for a cute WR to root for, he just doesn’t make the cut.
44. Mike Williams – ESPN Ranking - 39
Not much to say about this guy. I don’t know much about him because I hardly ever get to see Tampa Bay play (perhaps my comrade Keisha will have some thoughts).
45. DeAngelo Williams – ESPN Ranking - 30
Great running back. Yeah, that’s it. Would probably kick him out of bed, if I gain the appropriate amount of leg strength.
46. Steven Jackson – ESPN Ranking - 19
His hair is far too long. If I was a player, and if it was legal, I would just grab onto it anytime he tried to run by. But I am guessing there is some sort of penalty for that. Unnecessary roughness perhaps? Gets hurt relatively often, but I can’t blame the guy. For his prime football playing years, he was all St. Louis had to cheer about.
47. Ahmad Bradshaw – ESPN Ranking - 33
He plays for a team I think is super boring and I don’t find him the least bit exciting. And he doesn’t make me do a head turn. So hence, he falls to the bottom of our list.
48. Dewayne Bowe – ESPN Ranking - 37
Made some not so smart comments last year about the booty shenanigans players participate in on the road. Even if he could buy me all of the finer things, I wouldn’t give him a chance, because it would likely lead to me setting his house, car, clothes on fire. I tend to be a tad bit jealous, ladies (and perhaps gents). I don’t think a relationship would end well. Has tremendous potential, but only started really realizing it last year. Hopefully he keeps up his stats.
49. Jamaal Charles – ESPN Ranking - 4
Most guys will probably think these rankings are a joke because two of the top RBs fall to the bottom of the list. But this list isn’t about how good a player is, they are about how cute the player is. So yeah, Mr. Charles you lose.
50. Chris Johnson – ESPN Ranking - 3
I don’t even know where to start with this man. He is not at all attractive. Talks funny. Thinks he deserves the most money every year and holds out almost every year. Just play the damn game!! You don’t deserve the big money when your stats aren’t any better than anyone else’s. I could go on and on about my problems with CJ, but perhaps we will revisit him in another post.
I just finished both of my fantasy football drafts, and Keisha has a couple yet to go. I like to think I did pretty well - picking both for looks and actual talent. Of course a lot of fantasy football is about luck and who you are playing that week (if you do head to head), so why not have some fun with it?
Good luck!